"I love this color!! I was a bit apprehensive after reading some reviews about how red everyone said it was. I'm glad I took the chance and tried it anyway. It's the PERFECT brown with a hint of warmth. If that's what you're looking for, this is your color. I will be purchasing this color again really soon!!" — Sekret (5/5)
TURNED MY HAIR GREEN "Hello I am NOT satisfied with my cat-tail colored hair dye. I colored my virgin BLONDE hair with this dye; I previously had terfic results with there bright colored hair dye but this time. . . MY HAIR TURNED GREEN! I am not exaggerating at all my hair looked like a darker version of Oscar the grouch. If your hair is blonde be careful using the color catail. Best regards Linda" — Linda (1/5)
Fantastic color and price "I’m a medium brunette that is transitioning gray (over 50% and root line) and needed a dye that wouldn’t damage my hair compared to Demi or perm, while allowing my gray to grow out slowly without a harsh line. This color is fantastic and covers or masks most of my grays for a decent amount of time. If you are looking to have 100% gray coverage without a trace that you may have it, then this is not for you. You will have some indicators that you have gray if you look closely enough. As it fades with multiple washes, it still does a great job dulling any metallic sheen from going gray. Honestly, not spending hundreds of dollars every 4 weeks to sit in a chair for hours just to “touch up”… and instead, spending a couple dollars and a couple hours every 30-45 days in the luxury of my home while not killing my hair, makes me feel like I found some sort of unknown cheat code for a person trying to mask grays for a bit. 10/10 recommend. Disclaimer: I have extreme bed head in this photo because this is the time I chose write a review but wanted to be transparent about the coverage level." — Annie (5/5)
Redder than expected "Just so you know, it's VERY red. I had platinum hair before and used this and my hair is red, no brown in sight." — Becca (4/5)
LIGHT brown, didn’t mix well "First time trying the supernaturals collection to try to cover my greys. I mixed 2/3rds cattail with 1/3 vampire red & the red totally overpowered. Took nice on my greys and blended sooo evenly, what I expect from manic panic, why I always come back to the brand. Just a word to the dyehards that this color is LIGHT & my hair is a rich red with some more burgundy tones but it did Not show up with any brown in a mix with the vampire red. Gonna experiment again for a more natural look" — Abbigale (3/5)
"Great coverage and such a pretty color!! I’ve been using manic panic since I was 13 lol definitely one of my favorite brands:)" — Neely (5/5)